Yup, the folks who can get away with pucks are generally in northern climates that drain to winterize and get snow melt in the pool all winter.I’d probably get away with pucks only. Our pool is open only five months of the year and when I open it after the winter the CYA is usually zero. I always have to drain some water after one of our heavy thunderstorms. I’m too fussy about my pool chemistry to let it fall to chance though. I am very proud of the fact that when the pool company comes to open or close our pool they always comment on how the liner looks new and are surprised it’s from 2008. I credit TFP and diligent testing for that.