Coleman vs. Summerwaves?

[Wetcat]

Thanks for such a source of info here.

I'm hoping experience from some of you could help guide a decision for us. We're comparing two similar AGPs.
Both are 16' x 48" round, one made by Summerwaves and one made by Coleman.

The Summerwaves is $277 and a link to it here: Summer Waves Elite 16 Premium Frame Above Ground Swimming Pool with Filter Pump System And Deluxe Accessory Set - Walmart.com
The Coleman a little more at $298 and a link to it here: Coleman Power Steel 16 Frame Swimming Pool Set with Filter Pump, Ladder, Cover and Maintenance Kit - Walmart.com

We previously had a SummerEscapes pool, which I imagine has been replaced by Summerwaves. We were happy with it and still have the pump from that one, so perhaps it would be a bonus to have a spare pump if we bought the Summerwaves?

Any guidance is very much appreciated. Thank you.

 

[chayne]

i have had one of each. i like the Coleman better. it seems the liner is a bit better. i have had the Coleman now for 2 years. i will be going to Intex next year. my Coleman liner has faded out pretty good is the only thing i have against it.

 

[splashpad]

@Wetcat

Which one did you go with? (curious)