Any in ground through wall skimmers "best"?

Aug 11, 2017
37
Chelmsford MA
This may seem like an odd question but genuinely curious if there are any in ground through wall skimmers that just seem to be better than most. I have an old Hayward one with a weird basket design that has a sleeve that slips over a port of some sort. Drives me nuts because I can only get one type of basket for it and the handle always breaks, and I would love to get one with a weir gate. Other than size and vinyl wall compatibility, any thing else to consider or are they all pretty much the same? I have pavers that I can replace or cut if I need to change shape so not too worried about that. Thanks in advance!
 
My widemouth Hayward skimmers are no joke. They look normal in the wall, but this pic when I opened the box puts it into better perspective.

20220416_141313.jpg
Screenshot_20240610_075432_Gallery.jpg

The parts are all readily available being a flagship model.


My older model was more rectangular but they've since went with a square door and a wider throat. I don't see any difference in ability but in theory, the smaller door has the same flow over a smaller area making more pull.

Screenshot_20240610_074345_Gallery.jpg
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.