AGP wall rusted / need to replace/ need help on order of fix to reduce future work

HeidiP

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2017
126
Ottawa/ON, Canada
SEND TIPS on how to make this run smoothly/moral support?


I have a 12x24 oval AGP (Salt...hahaha) that was installed 2017. Due to my own issues not watching the eyeball/dripping- the wall had rusted last season that ended up as a hole. This spring the wall has pushed out of the channel where it's rusted out/split open.
CURRENT STATE
We are coming out of thaw but there is still a large chunk of ice on the pool. Usually it's gone by - May?

Fortunately I don't have a lake yet, it isn't leaking, but the liner is visible (there's a visible area about 1 foot square.

Last year I found a hole in the wall in the spring and drained down to 6" and repaired the wall riveting steel, then refilled. Obviously I should have replaced the entire wall (since it's a long continuous sheet) but I was hoping I could work fast and keep the liner for longer.

I assume I will have to disassemble, drain, remove liner, replace wall, and then rebuild pool bottom and build pool back up. It's a buttress free pool frame with straps that run the width of the pool in 2 spots about 6 feet in on each end.

How do I keep my bottom from getting ruined/having to do major work on this? OR conversely- is this the time to say screw it and dig down 2 feet to sink the pool a little bit? (I'd love to have better sight lines in the yard.)



POTENTIAL PLAN
Drain to a foot, to keep the ice block floating for less damage to the bottom, with much of water gone, reducing chances of flood into my house/neighbor's.
Order a replacement wall for about $2K Canadian and replacement liner.
Wait for ice to melt, drain fully, disassemble and reinstall wall, smooth out bottom again, install liner.

Really lamenting not having more handy friends at this point, but i may have to throw money at it too since I have 4 kids to manage.
 
That can be a sticky situation. If you do get a new wall, be sure that the rest of the structure of the pool (including the wall channels, bottom straps, pressure plates, and bottom plates) is also in good condition. You don't want to order a new wall and find that the other parts are rusted and also need to be replaced. If you are already spending $2000 for a new wall you may want to investigate the cost of a whole new pool (I know you didn't want to hear that....).
 
  • Like
Reactions: HeidiP and Newdude
+1.

It'll be at least a couple hundred for the liner and $3k is the entry level for 12×24 pools. Some are pre season sale-d for $2700 right now.
Great point!! There are some great deals right now. I've looked at brand new (some good deals) vs replacement wall ($2K with tax Canadian $) - I won't make the call until I get the pool drained and somewhat disassembled. Here's what I'm thinking. What am I missing?

PRO NEW POOL
Approx $3K with tax for lower grade model
Everything new
Other parts on mine may fail
Fresh and clean
Reliance that a new warranty starts fresh
Have to refresh bottom / level of site after spring rains either way


PRO REPLACE WALL
$2k wall, $500 liner
Replacing same pool $7,500 with tax and shipping.
(I have one of the most $/sturdy pools on the market- except the darned wall. All resin otherwise)
Narrow area in yard already levelled for buttress-free / would have to level for buttresses another few feet out - keeping to code 4 feet from house and property line could mean smaller pool to account for buttresses
Cheapest on-sale pool is still more $ than new wall and liner
Some components already assembled/can leave track and uprights in place
Resin parts in really good shape/sturdy (9" top rails, 7" uprights)
54" pool vs standard 52" (we are all tall, every extra inch is great) - minor pro

- but my yard is narrow so adding buttresses (and levelling more yard to account for them) may be the thing that tips me to keeping same pool with new wall unless something else comes up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
That can be a sticky situation. If you do get a new wall, be sure that the rest of the structure of the pool (including the wall channels, bottom straps, pressure plates, and bottom plates) is also in good condition. You don't want to order a new wall and find that the other parts are rusted and also need to be replaced. If you are already spending $2000 for a new wall you may want to investigate the cost of a whole new pool (I know you didn't want to hear that....).
Definitely worth considering everything- and I need to see everything taken apart to decide. Last year I did a hail-mary wall repair with some riveting steel- I should have bought a pool wall from someone and riveted a larger area vs my square patches - to spread the pressure better - or replaced at that time.

After fixing it and still having to deal with it this year, I have learned my lesson to fully investigate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude