Newb Looking for Basic Guidance on Smart Controller Options

mattvandyk

Member
May 19, 2019
5
Kalamazoo, Michigan
So, in my preliminary research on this, there are 3 primary options -- Hayward Omnihub, Pentair Intellicenter, and Jandy-something -- but the internet is kind of a mess on the subject, so I don't know what else is out there, whether any of these fall into the "hard avoid" category, and whether there's a general consensus on which one is "best." I know from experience in other areas that there are often lots of options for devices that do similar things, but the community tends to settle on one that rises to the top, and I'm wondering if that's the case here too.

I have the following:
  • 25,000 gallon basic rectangle vinyl in-ground pool (2 returns, 1 skimmer, 1 vac)
  • Hayward SWG setup w/ Aquarite 900 panel & TCell 940 cell.
  • Rheem Heater
  • Intellipro VSF Pump
I would like to install a smart controller (ideally controlled by a smartphone app; integration with HomeKit or HomeAssistant, a plus, but not necessary) that can do all of the following:
  • monitor pH, FC, and salt (others would be nice, but not necessary)
  • adjust the chlorine output from the SWG (ideally, automatically based on the FC levels reported by the monitor)
  • notify me if pH is high or low with instructions on what to add and how much
  • notify me if salt is low with instructions of how much to add
  • allow me to put the VS pump on a schedule and otherwise adjust speeds remotely
  • allow me to open/close valves (drain, skimmer, vac) remotely
  • allow me to turn on/off, and adjust temp on heater remotely
This would also be nice, but I haven’t even found a product that does this, so this is, at least as far as I know, imaginary:
  • add pH Up or pH Down preloaded into some sort of hopper/reservoir, as necessary (again, ideally automatically based on the FC levels reported by the monitor)
 
Automation is real good at controlling things such as pumps, lights, heaters, and valve actuators. However, monitoring pool chemistry and automated chemical additions are much more challenging. Not too many of us embrace this challenge. Pentair IntelliChem is probably one of the better recognized systems out there. Take a look at its capabilities and limitations. Search TFP for additional information. If I recall correctly @Dirk has this system and may have some comments.

As far as automation goes, much of it depends on your current equipment. If you have Pentair equipment, IntelliCenter would be the best choice. There are different versions so make sure you choose the one that meets your pool's requirements.

There are several form members that have built their own system and utilize nodejs-poolcontroller.


There are many different ways to automate equipment, including simple Wi-Fi relays and switches. I built my own DIY system for dummies. You can check out the link in my signature.

And then, there is the other side of the dummy spectrum. Check out this link.