Recommendations for SWG

GMacdonald

Member
May 8, 2023
8
Bucks County, PA
Pool Size
25000
Surface
Plaster
Chlorine
Liquid Chlorine
Hi all,

We are looking to convert from liquid chlorine to SWG this year shortly after opening - this is all new to us but we've heard good things in terms of maintenance and ease of use, in addition to it being not as harsh on hair/skin as liquid chlorine. Though cost is likely the same in the long run, we're excited to not be lugging gallons of chlorine back & forth all the time. Looking for recommendations as to what type of SWG system may be the best for pool...

Pool is 25,000 gallons, so we've been targeting systems rated for around 50k gallons (2x). Our system (below) is pretty old - the pool was originally put in in the 80s, no filter automation (just runs on a timer), and pretty sure our pump is just a single speed. Filter is brand new as of last season and is a cartridge filter, but because some parts of the system are still very old and may need to be replaced in time - we would likely opt to replace with SuperFlo VSP / Easy Touch Automation, so we would prefer an SWG system that will be compatible with that in the future + work for us for now. Ignore the old caretaker system and heater you see pictured, both have been disconnected.

Our pool company who has usually been pretty good has recommended the Solaxx Resilience E Series 60 + (18) 40 lb bags of salt to start. Does anyone have any experience with this one and can confirm if it's a good option? From reading through various threads here we were considering the Circu Pool RJ-45 or RJ-60, possibly the Hayward AquaRite T-15 - but it seems like that's only rated for 40,000 which may be cutting it a little low for the size of our pool, and it didn't have as high of reviews on this site: Compare and Review Saltwater Chlorine Generator Prices and Features | DSP. Some of the Auto Pilot/Pool Pilot options also seemed to have good reviews, but not sure if they are compatible with our system. Have also seen a few mentions of the Pentair Intellchlor IC40 on here, but don't see it anywhere on that list - is that one we should stay away from? And just to be sure, once we put the system in, it'll just be replacement of the cell every ~3-5 years?

We'll likely have our pool company do the installation just to save ourselves some time.

Appreciate any input or recommendations!!

IMG_2489.jpegIMG_2491.jpegIMG_2490.jpeg
 
That sounds like a sub market SWG. You mention automation in the future. If you are definitely going that direction then try to keep your pump and your SWG within that same brand. Unfortunately, that means you have to look to the future and decide on a brand environment now. Pentair is the top choice on here followed by Hayward with Jandy a distant third. If you are instead going to maintain the timer that can be used with the SWG then the Circupool RJ60+ would be ideal for you. This would work for any VS pump you might add. If you get a Pentair VS3 pump then you can add the I/O board to it which can automate your SWG too. In case on got some of this wrong others will chime in.
 
With any automation system you will not need the timer. Without automation, if you run a pump, VS or not, by itself and add a SWG then you will need the timer for the SWG so it turns on after the pump starts and turns off before the pump does so that there's no risk of the SWG being on without water running. In this case, if you upgrade to a VS pump then it will not be controlled by your timer but rather it has to be hard wired to the power source as the VS has it's own timer system in the motor control panel.