Fiberglass main seam repair or replace with new fiberglass or tear out and replace with gunite

Nov 20, 2018
19
Newnan, GA
Hi there -- We are long-time pool owners (15-year-old 23-40 pebble-tec pool) and are looking to purchase a new home in a different state. One of the homes we like has a 17-year-old pool that has sat in an unused state for 3 years. The seller's Disclosure states the fiberglass pool has a crack on the main seam.

We know a lot about maintaining the pool -- nothing about constructing or doing this type of repair. Trying to determine our options before making an offer on this house.

1. Can a main seam on a fiberglass pool even be repaired? The pool has been uncovered for 3 years through all weather snow and ice. It looks rough. Even if the seam could be repaired I would imagine the surface would be stained and have other issues. So attempting a repair might be low on our list.

2. Can you lift an old fiberglass pool out of the hole and just put in a new one? How would they even come up with a perfect match for the whole?

3. Would it be best to remove the old fiberglass and go back with concrete and pebble-tec? If yes, would they need to tear out all of the decking and start over from scratch? Would it cost as much as a new pool which today is about $75K++ for one this size?

The house itself is pretty rough - been vacant for a while and renters before that. but it is a nice area and frankly, there is not much on the market.




------
Update post after reading the replies -- thank you thank you thank you to all who responded. We had not even thought about converting this into a vinyl pool. Our budget for the pool renovation project is $25K - $30K and I think doing some changes to the plumbing, installing the pool liner and replacing the mechanicals could be done with 30K. Hopefully. The pool is located in Missouri and we also planned to build a pool enclosure to extend the season (different budget) so I don't think a vinyl pool would be negative at all.

Love the Troublefree pool forum
 

Attachments

  • pool.JPG
    pool.JPG
    28.8 KB · Views: 23
  • poolold.JPG
    poolold.JPG
    62.9 KB · Views: 24
Last edited:
Hi there -- We are long-time pool owners (15-year-old 23-40 pebble-tec pool) and are looking to purchase a new home in a different state. One of the homes we like has a 17-year-old pool that has sat in an unused state for 3 years. The seller's Disclosure states the fiberglass pool has a crack on the main seam.

We know a lot about maintaining the pool -- nothing about constructing or doing this type of repair. Trying to determine our options before making an offer on this house.

1. Can a main seam on a fiberglass pool even be repaired? The pool has been uncovered for 3 years through all weather snow and ice. It looks rough. Even if the seam could be repaired I would imagine the surface would be stained and have other issues. So attempting a repair might be low on our list.

2. Can you lift an old fiberglass pool out of the hole and just put in a new one? How would they even come up with a perfect match for the whole?

3. Would it be best to remove the old fiberglass and go back with concrete and pebble-tec? If yes, would they need to tear out all of the decking and start over from scratch? Would it cost as much as a new pool which today is about $75K++ for one this size?

The house itself is pretty rough - been vacant for a while and renters before that. but it is a nice area and frankly, there is not much on the market.
How much money do you want to spend on repairing or replacing the pool?
 
Fiberglass pools don’t have a main seam or any seams. That pool is negative value to the house. Assume there is no “pool” and you would be buying a house with a hole in the ground.

Every house had its price.
 
Maybe it's a 'hybrid pool' with a concrete floor and fiberglass walls, those have seams. It's getting harder and harder to find people to repair them.

Either way, if it's structurally sound, you can drop a liner in there for $5000 to $7500.
 
Maybe it's a 'hybrid pool' with a concrete floor and fiberglass walls, those have seams. It's getting harder and harder to find people to repair them.

Either way, if it's structurally sound, you can drop a liner in there for $5000 to $7500.
That’s a good point I didn’t think about converting it to a liner pool. Probably the least expensive option although $7500 seems pretty cheap for running new plumbing and all that stuff that would need to go for a liner pool after removing a fiberglass shell.
 
$7500 seems pretty cheap for running new plumbing and all that stuff that would need to go for a liner pool
I was guestimating just the liner, leaving plenty of 'pain tolerance' funding leftover for equipment and anything else that needs doing.


after removing a fiberglass shell.
Said shell is the support/walls for the liner. (If it's structurally sound).
 
Hi there -- We are long-time pool owners (15-year-old 23-40 pebble-tec pool) and are looking to purchase a new home in a different state. One of the homes we like has a 17-year-old pool that has sat in an unused state for 3 years. The seller's Disclosure states the fiberglass pool has a crack on the main seam.

We know a lot about maintaining the pool -- nothing about constructing or doing this type of repair. Trying to determine our options before making an offer on this house.

1. Can a main seam on a fiberglass pool even be repaired? The pool has been uncovered for 3 years through all weather snow and ice. It looks rough. Even if the seam could be repaired I would imagine the surface would be stained and have other issues. So attempting a repair might be low on our list.

2. Can you lift an old fiberglass pool out of the hole and just put in a new one? How would they even come up with a perfect match for the whole?

3. Would it be best to remove the old fiberglass and go back with concrete and pebble-tec? If yes, would they need to tear out all of the decking and start over from scratch? Would it cost as much as a new pool which today is about $75K++ for one this size?

The house itself is pretty rough - been vacant for a while and renters before that. but it is a nice area and frankly, there is not much on the market.




------
Update post after reading the replies -- thank you thank you thank you to all who responded. We had not even thought about converting this into a vinyl pool. Our budget for the pool renovation project is $25K - $30K and I think doing some changes to the plumbing, installing the pool liner and replacing the mechanicals could be done with 30K. Hopefully. The pool is located in Missouri and we also planned to build a pool enclosure to extend the season (different budget) so I don't think a vinyl pool would be negative at all.

Love the Troublefree pool forum



What did you end up doing? I am in the same boat…
 

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support