New gas valve arrived today. It took about 90 minutes to replace the valve - novice gas fitter here. Thanks all for ferreting out the issue.
View attachment 437946View attachment 437947
The burner assembly came out without too much trouble. Not sure if it is normal for the burner tubes to appear more oxidized toward the back. Underside of burner tubes looked very clean.
The heater fired up first try after replacing the valve. Adjusted temp down and heater shut off as expected. Adjusted heat up again and it fired up without issues.
Last question: it appeared that the pilot light stayed lit after the burners fired up. Is that normal? The pilot does shut off when the main burners shut down.
Joe M in WV