I appreciate the input. Basically I got the unit for free from someone closing their pool. Forgetting installation costs, which would have been the same for new heater, I've put in about $325 in parts. It's frustrating because I feel that with your advice I've gotten very close to having it run, although obviously I can't know for sure until I try and fix the next issue. If it's the ignitor, it's another $40, no big deal. But if I have to replace the gas valve, that's $225, and that's a little more significant. But my total would still be a lot less than a new heater, which I'm seeing for $1800 cheapest for the same model.
Is there a way to check if the gas valve needs to be cleaned out and to do that? I've heard about obstructions due to spider webs, etc., but don't know if that could apply in the valve as well. Also, when the knob on the valve is open, what, if anything, does pushing it in do? Is that a priming mechanism?
Thanks