Please understand that non chlorine shock (mps or sodium persulfate)
are only oxidizers not sanitizers.
Chlorine is both a sanitizer and an oxidizer.
The majority of spas that see any use at all need more than 5ppm of fc per week to remain sanitary even if an oxidizer is keeping it looking clear.
If fc is below min for your cya at any time nasties
will proliferate.
See—>
FC/CYA Levels
There was an instance not long ago where someone was using a certain non chlorine shock & it also skewed the fc results not just the cc results. I haven’t been able to find it yet to link it.
At any rate, I suggest that you discontinue your use of “non chlorine shock ” products & stick with using liquid chlorine (if your cya is already 30+) as both your oxidizer & sanitizer keeping fc above minimum at all times & allow the oxidizer you have been using to dissipate. I suspect doing so you will see your test results will start to make sense.
* sulfates are not only irritating but also can damage your heater as they build up.
Most here only use them occasionally if ever. They are not necessary to maintain a spa in most cases.
Why use 2 things (oxidizer + sanitizer) when you can just use one thing (chlorine) that does both when used adequately?
I personally have never used non chlorine shock in my spa or pool and likely never will.
As a test of you may try adding 2 or 3ppm worth of liquid chlorine then seeing what your fc & oto results are.
If you have a question about any information within this Sticky, please start a new thread for yourself where you will receive very quick responses to your specific questions. Thank you! Introduction There are two main things to consider when maintaining your hot tub water, Water Balance and...
www.troublefreepool.com