Yes, I do recommend the Intex unit for people on a tight budget, just disconnect the cable to the copper bar portion of the unit. The AquaTrol has a built-in timer that can also control the pump, so the SWG and pump are kept in sync, it also has a much better review history, and produces more chlorine than the less expensive units. The ChlorEase has a fairly mixed review history, a relatively small chlorine production capacity, and tends to need to be cleaned frequently.