Sorry, been so busy but finally got the patch stuff and went out there over the weekend with Bob.
Chief, the water at that point is around 5' deep since I drained down to the light niche and the delamination between the two plaster coats is on the bottom. The thing is, we are in the middle of a drought out here in California and just draining the pool down to the light niche as I did will make it rather costly to fill the pool back up. As it turned out, we were able to fish the new light cord right up through the old metal conduit, which had been cut just below the concrete. So we didn't need to trench down to behind the niche, and I actually didn't need to drain out that water. (I feel a bit foolish about that.)
I just ordered a 10lb container of the E-Z Patch 1FS. We started by trying out the patch material on a small delam and it worked great. As I had read in the reviews, the hardest part is getting the mixed patch material down to the defect. The reason is that as soon as it gets into the water it starts to "dissolve", so it is hard to get it to the right spot, and then again it makes a huge cloud, like a smoke screen.
What we did was put the mixed patch material in a tupperware container with the lid on and take it down. I was down there trying to wave the smoke away with a 6" putty knife. One thing we will do differently next time will be to turn the container over and put it right on the defect before removing the lid. My suggestion was to put it in a large ziplock freezer bag, take it down, slit the bottom a few inches, and squeeze it onto the defect, but I was overruled, at least this time.
Once it is on the defect, and you can wave away the smoke, it works great. (Disclaimer -- no idea how long it might last though.) The first patch, about 4" square, was beautiful, although slightly it is slightly lighter (white) than the pool plaster. Barely noticeable difference though.
So now I'm waiting for the new order of E-Z Patch to come. I got a pretty good sunburn on my back while I was at it, I generally stay out of the sun, but I was so engrossed that I lost track of the time.
Now I want to confess something else that is embarassing as heck for me. I really didn't know how bad it was for plaster to be dry, and as it happened we were hit with three consecutive heat waves and now a fourth.
Examination of the bottom of the pool revealed many smaller delaminations, so I know there were already problems with the plaster. But looking at the sides of the pool, I have noticed some vertical hairline cracks about two feet apart on one side of the pool. If I tap along the side, it sounds hollow underneath those areas, and solid in between. So I don't know if draining the water to the pool niche and not filling it right back up may have caused that. Also there are a couple of areas along that side where the plaster is bulging a little bit in two areas, each about 4" x 3". One more thing, the edge of one of the steps crumbled like chalk, about 4 inches wide, above the lowered water line.
But I wanted to work on the delams on the bottom and I didn't know if I would be draining the pool the rest of the way versus attempting an underwater patch.
In addition, there it some thing flaky delamination just under the new waterline along the other side, maybe for about two feet horizontal by three inches.
I feel like a total dope and this is what happens when amateurs think they know it all. Not completely sure if this was already there before I drained it though. ( ? )
All is not lost however. I can patch pretty much everything. The hairline cracks don't matter too much and I'm not worried about leaking as there is a plaster layer underneath.
The thing that most concerns me is the two little bulges in the wall, there is a little give to them when I push gently on them. I don't really want to start messing with them !
I talked to a local pool plasterer, a complete re-plaster would run $4500 - 5500. It would involved demolition of all the old plaster and starting from scratch. There is some other remediation needed such as ~1.5" subsidence of the concrete deck on one side. It doesn't absolutely need to be fixed immediately though. Nothing I can't handle in any case.
The pool is 53 years old and has been replastered with the new plaster being applied over the old plaster.
OK that's about it, it is enough, isn't it ?