Chlorine is chlorine. Liquid chlorine from a pool supply is Sodium Hypochlorite. Regular laundry bleach is Sodium Hypochlorite. They will only differ in strength, which may generally be 5.25-6% for bleach, and 6-12% for the 'liquid shock'. Prices are usually comparable per strength and volume, so it'll come down to how many jugs to lug. The pool calculator ( http://poolcalculator.com/ ) is your friend.