Solid or liquid CYA / Stabilizer ??

Trickplay461

Member
May 28, 2016
9
Egg Harbor Township
Just curious what people recommend I'm leaning toward trying to liquid stabilizer since it registers instantly versus waiting a week for the solid granules. I can get it for $27 a gallon delivered to my front door which though more expensive seems like such a deal to me, the local pool store wants $36. I just bought some and I would love to hear if any owners here have any experience with it and what's their two cents on it. :)
 

Texas Splash

Mod Squad
TFP Expert
LifeTime Supporter
The liquid conditioner is nicknamed "liquid gold" because of that price compared to about $16 for the granules. Certainly up to you though if it's more convenient and the added cost is reasonable. FYI - We did some studies last season and determined it doesn't take a full week for granule stabilizer to show-up on the CYA test. In fact, once the granules are dissolved (sock-soaking method), the CYA should reach (or be very close to) the target in about 24-48 hours.
 

spinPHD

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2017
500
Phoenix
After my drain and refill, I wanted to get cya in faster so went with one bottle of the liquid. I still needed more and didn't want to pay so much again, so added the other 15 cya via sock method.

I'm impatient person, but after experience with both I would say the extra cost isn't worth it. The granuals are very simple, and it all registered on test for me within 24 hours
 

drharris

Well-known member
Jun 29, 2016
275
Walhalla, SC
You can do what I did and try to get 4 lbs granular dissolved in a bucket of water first! Bam, instant liquid stabilizer!

Spoiler alert, though: it's not fun. And not instant.
 

spinPHD

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2017
500
Phoenix
I wish I would have done this, but if you're in middle of a full refill you can tie a sock full of the granuals to the hose used for filling the pool. By the time pool is filled, you will have CYA in it.
 

Uncle Salty

Gold Supporter
Feb 3, 2017
244
South Carolina
Just make sure you shake the heck out of it before and during application and dip the jug in the water when you think you're done and shake some more as you'll want to get all the liquid gold you paid for.

Salty
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sunnymosmile

Mendy48

Bronze Supporter
Apr 27, 2018
575
Midland, MI
I think I may stick with the liquid stabilizer next time. I'm so annoyed right now at how some of my granular sunk to the pool floor using the soak method. I've used these same socks last year to add CYA to my pool (granular), and no problem. Now, I have some ... just some.... granular on the floor of my pool. I had to brush them to the Main Drain (vacuum later, since its already 8:30 pm). Where can I get the liquid stabilizer? Though I don't think I'll need it any time soon since I just added CYA. But for future references...
 

Uncle Salty

Gold Supporter
Feb 3, 2017
244
South Carolina
I think I may stick with the liquid stabilizer next time. I'm so annoyed right now at how some of my granular sunk to the pool floor using the soak method. I've used these same socks last year to add CYA to my pool (granular), and no problem. Now, I have some ... just some.... granular on the floor of my pool. I had to brush them to the Main Drain (vacuum later, since its already 8:30 pm). Where can I get the liquid stabilizer? Though I don't think I'll need it any time soon since I just added CYA. But for future references...
Amazon, just search liquid stabilizer. I just had 2 gallons delivered yesterday.

Salty
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mendy48

Other Threads of Interest