Update: pulled the motor, started to remove the seal plate, bolt broke off in the seal plate. Dang. Now new motor and seal plate. Went to pool parts place, they had an equipment sale going on, offered me a complete new pump for $60 over the parts. Decided to just replace the whole thing. Much easier than putting the old one back together, putting in new seals, etc. So now have a new pentaire Superflo pump, looking at years of hopefully trouble-free use.