I'm surprised the tiles ended up clashing so much. We went with a cobalt tile over PebbleSheen Blue Surf and we feel like it looks great.
Me too, to be honest. And of course today in the sun the plaster looked very blue, where yesterday it looked very green. If you search photos of sapphire treasure pools they’re very blue…but the thumbnail that WetEdge uses (in my post above) shows that the base is kind of teal. They actually use “Mediterranean blue” pigment in the plaster. Oh well. We wanted white, was sold white, chose white, etc….if we kept the blue we would’ve probably forever regretted it just a little. And I’ll probably forever regret making them switch to the white if there’s any noticeable tells of the redo