- May 20, 2016
- 37
- Pool Size
- 25000
- Surface
- Vinyl
- Chlorine
- Salt Water Generator
- SWG Type
- Pentair Intellichlor IC-60
Starting out by saying that I have the full TF-100 test kit plus the K-1766 Sodium Chloride test kit and I use them religiously and have for 5 years. Recently my IC-60 stopped reading the salt content of the water correctly (shutting it down) and in the interim, trying to prove to the pool service company that there was, indeed, a reading error, I took a sample of my water in and had it tested on a machine. The IC-60 unit was bad and has been replaced under warranty - it was literally 6 months old!!
Anyway, the readout I got back from the pool water test was off A LOT in a couple of areas and I wanted to inquire as to whether this is the norm. It seems that being off +/- 10% would be OK but these numbers are ridiculously incorrect. Here is what I came up with using my TF-100:
Salt: 3200 (this is low, it just rained, after it evaps I will add salt if I need to)
FC 8
CC 0
PH 7.5
CYA 70/80 (small vial comparator @ 80, large TFTestkits vial @ 70)
TA 60 (bringing this up to 75, added soda this morning)
CH 375
Here is what the pool water test said:
Salt: 3200
FC 9
CC 0
PH 7.5
CYA 110
TA 35
CH 125
So the glaring difference are in the CYA, TA and CH readings. Have you guys ever seen something that far off on a water test? I follow the instructions implicitly on the drop tests including wiping the tip of the bottle between drops of R-0009 on the TA test. I am stumped as to why the pool water test is so far off....I mean, not even CLOSE. There is no way my CYA is 110 based on the tube test. TA took 6 drops to change colors = 60. CH drop test took 15 drops likewise x 25 = 375.
Thoughts and musings?
Thanks!
Anyway, the readout I got back from the pool water test was off A LOT in a couple of areas and I wanted to inquire as to whether this is the norm. It seems that being off +/- 10% would be OK but these numbers are ridiculously incorrect. Here is what I came up with using my TF-100:
Salt: 3200 (this is low, it just rained, after it evaps I will add salt if I need to)
FC 8
CC 0
PH 7.5
CYA 70/80 (small vial comparator @ 80, large TFTestkits vial @ 70)
TA 60 (bringing this up to 75, added soda this morning)
CH 375
Here is what the pool water test said:
Salt: 3200
FC 9
CC 0
PH 7.5
CYA 110
TA 35
CH 125
So the glaring difference are in the CYA, TA and CH readings. Have you guys ever seen something that far off on a water test? I follow the instructions implicitly on the drop tests including wiping the tip of the bottle between drops of R-0009 on the TA test. I am stumped as to why the pool water test is so far off....I mean, not even CLOSE. There is no way my CYA is 110 based on the tube test. TA took 6 drops to change colors = 60. CH drop test took 15 drops likewise x 25 = 375.
Thoughts and musings?
Thanks!
Last edited: