A question about replacing pool water

May 4, 2012
14
#1
Hello All,

I was browsing the forum and clicked a link which took me to another pool forum, where I found "One hundred reasons for a cloudy pool" and one of the reasons was: 13.Swimming pool water has not been replaced in 5 years or more.

Should pool water be replaced every five years?
 

BoDarville

TFP Expert
LifeTime Supporter
Jun 5, 2012
3,843
DFW, Texas
#2
russ.stevenson:

Welcome to TFP! :wave:

I would replace water only if your test results dictate a need to do so - never because of an arbitrary timetable. Two test items I would look at first are your CYA and CH levels. You need some of both items in your pool water, but too much of either can be problematic. If your CYA level is over 90, and/or your CH is over 400, then I would look at replacing a portion of your pool water. How much water should be replaced depends on what your test results are.

For more information, click the Pool Calculator link in my signature. The links in the left-most column will give you more information on each test item. In addition, at the bottom of the calculator, you can enter information about your pool (chlorine source, pool surface, etc.) and gallons (gallons is at the top of the calculator) to get target amounts for each item. Then, based on your test results, the calculator will tell you the % of water that should be replaced (if any).

If you do replace some water, don't forget to retest after the procedure and make any necessary adjustments.
 
May 4, 2012
14
#4
Thanks for the replies. My numbers are good and my pool is now sparkling, thanks to you good folks. I still have a little ways to go, but i can see the bottom in the deep end and I took my first swim yesterday. I will post some pics as soon as my wife turns over the camera. This is my first pool and I must say it's kinda fun taking care of it. My wife thinks I'm obsessed.
 

Suziqzer

TFP Expert
Sep 21, 2009
914
Greentown, IN
#7
Lol.... We probably all get that from time to time, but it's great when someone else comes over who has a pool and asks how you get your water so clean and clear. DH always say, "Ask the wife". Love it!
 

Speedo

LifeTime Supporter
May 4, 2011
636
#8
We had some friends over a few weeks ago and David's wife mentioned that she could see a trail in the water from his sunblock (I do believe it was mentioned that he put too much on though). They're not pool owners so they have no clue how clear it has to be for that to happen. I've never even noticed it myself.

My Fiance mentions how clear it is, quite often and she's very happy. It's nice to have your work appreciated.

russ.stevenson said:
"One hundred reasons for a cloudy pool" and one of the reasons was: 13.Swimming pool water has not been replaced in 5 years or more.
I can't believe some of the things people will say to cover the fact that they don't know how to properly maintain their pools.
 

linen

TFP Expert
LifeTime Supporter
Jul 30, 2010
8,649
Twin Cities, MN
#9
russ.stevenson said:
I was browsing the forum and clicked a link which took me to another pool forum, where I found "One hundred reasons for a cloudy pool" and one of the reasons was: 13.Swimming pool water has not been replaced in 5 years or more.
I assume that was off of the "poolsolutions" site? If it is, that is Ben Powell's site, who the poolforum.com where the BBB method developed (I think). I read that list as kind of a catchall/brainstorming list. I am guessing here, but I wonder if Ben included that one in reference to high cya concentrations in pools that do an occasional temporary "shock" using dichlor (or some other lower usage of a cya adding chlorination method). Another guess, is due to occasional temporary "shock" using cal-hypo, therefore slow build up of calcium in a pool. Thus emptying such a pool occasionally would "fix" or reset the concentration of calcium/cya to 0.

With that said, I would echo all of the comments above...no need for water replacement unless is warrented due to high concentrations of calcium hardness or cya.
 

brainchasm

Well-known member
Apr 26, 2012
47
#10
My ex (good terms) comes over to swim fairly often, and her running joke/compliment, especially when other people are around, is to look at the pool and go,

"Is there even water in it?"

"Yes, it's always filled up Meg."

"Oh ok, I couldn't tell, it's so clean! ;) "

And I smirk, and she grins, and someone usually asks me what I'm using...

LOL, good times!