Re: brown metal staining all over the pool lining, steps, sk
Welcome to TFP!
timb9 said:
The questions I have- should I filter the hose water any time I add water?
I have not tried any of the hose filters, so I cannot comment on their effectiveness. I did find an old post on the
Metal Trap that you might find interesting. Another albeit more expensive alternative is to consider looking into a whole-house water filter. Since this is a whole-house system, the higher cost would be compensated by reducing/eliminating any metal staining that could be present elsewhere in the house in addition to the pool.
timb9 said:
I am looking for a way to battle this without having to constantly add ascorbic acid and lower the chlorine levels, etc throughout the pool season- the whole process was aggravating and exhausting, not to mention expensive! If I can get rid of the stains one more time and keep a maintenance treatment with Metal Free throughout the summer, I will do that.
Unfortunately, there is no way to remove the metals short of draining and refilling with metal-free water. You will need to add a sequestrant periodically to keep the metals from redepositing as stains. Sequestrants slowly break down in the pool, so you need to add more regularly to maintain the correct level. However, Metal Free is not a product we recommend for this purpose.
Sequestrants based on HEDP, phosphonic acid, or phosphonic acid derivatives are the most effective. ProTeam's Metal Magic and Jack's Magic The Pink Stuff (regular), The Blue Stuff (fresh plaster), and The Purple Stuff (salt) are some of the top sequestrants. You can also find many other brands with similar active ingredients, some of which are noticeably less expensive.
timb9 said:
Is the staining going to happen every time the chlorine levels get high from shocking?
It will not always happen, but it is a risk. However, the good news is that if you keep your pool properly chlorinated for your CYA (stabilizer) level (see
Chlorine CYA Chart), you should not need to shock (or as we call it, SLAM) your pool. I have not shocked / SLAMmed in over two years.
timb9 said:
Should I attempt to remove the stains again before closing out the pool, which is happening quite soon (Nova Scotia), or wait until the spring?
I would wait until the spring. If you tried to remove them now, the stains would likely reappear by spring since sequestrants break down over time. So, no need to go through the effort and expense now for no gain. Once the water temperatures reach 50-60°F (10-15°C), then I would remove the stains using the
AA Treatment. By doing the AA treatment at those temperatures, the risk of an algae bloom is minimized vs. at warmer water temperatures. One thing you can try while performing the Ascorbic Acid Treatment is the "paper towel" method which involves putting put some paper towels in a skimmer. The paper towels may capture some of the metals, but there are no guarantees. However, it is a low-impact, low-cost method worth trying. You can read more about this method here:
Paper Towel Method. There is a pic towards the bottom of page 1. Even if the paper towel method removes some of the iron, you may still need to continue using a sequestrant but perhaps less of it if the paper towel method was at least somewhat successful in removing some of the metals.
A couple of suggestions to help us help you...
- Please add the state and nearest city in which you live to your profile. Don’t need specific town, nearest major city is fine. Your climate is important to the advice you receive. By doing this, it will appear in all your posts without you having to enter it each time. [/*:m:2fffa9km]
- Suggest adding information about your pool and related equipment in your signature. By doing this, it will automatically appear in all your posts so you do not have to re-enter it each time. If you have a SWG, please include those letters in your signature so it stands out as the advice for SWG vs. non-SWG is often different. [/*:m:2fffa9km]
Here's how to do both of the above:
Adding location to your profile and pool info to your signature.