Become a TFP Supporter Pool Math Forum Rules Pool School
Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Test kit/strip comparison

  1. Back To Top    #1
    AnnaK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Eastern Pennsylvania
    Posts
    1,132

    Test kit/strip comparison

    We all probably have collected a number of different test kits and strips over time. Last year I used a kit purchased at a pool store, the SwimLine 4-in-1, and when it began to give me results which I simply could not believe, I bought a Leslie's Deluxe DPD kit. That one was ok but I found the chlorine values not entirely believable. In October 2007 I ordered a kit from Dave, the TF-100 which has returned accurate and rialiable results every time. My husband is a chemist and did some laboratory magic with known quantities of Clorox dilutions as well as fancy pH meter tests, and his results were always in agreement with the TF-100 measurements. Hence, that's the one I go by.

    This morning I spent a little time testing my pool water with the various kits and strips in my collection. The strips and the SwimLine 4-in-1 are now in the trash. Attached is a PDF file with the results. I would have posted them directly but I can't figure out how to make a table here

    I'm a little puzzled by the CYA differences. The TF-100 reads at 70 ppm and the Blue Devil reads at 40 ppm. I would tend to agree with the lower value since it was 30 ppm when I closed last year and I haven't added any. It's true that I use trichlor but at a 1/4 setting on the feeder and the pucks having barely shrunk since I put them in a month ago it really can't have gone up by 40 ppm in just one month. More than likely I didn't read the test correctly.

    I'm not happy with the low chlorine readings on the Leslie's (Taylor chemicals) kit. I don't believe them. Possibly the chems are old.

    The point of this post really is to show the wild variances between tests and the inadequacy of test strips. A good test kit isn't inexpensive but in the long term it's a necessity.

    AnnaK
    Attached Files Attached Files
    — AnnaK —

    12,000 gal AGP, Hayward sand filter, Pentair 2-speed pump, timer.
    Please visit our Pool Issues pages for information about step weights, managing the solar cover, and PoolSkim.

  2. Back To Top    #2
    Guest
    Your results are not surprising. The leslie's kit is a rebranded Taylor, btw, which is why the pH and TA readings are the same but you most likely have a DPD test in the kit (with three liquid reagents) and a color comparator).

  3. Back To Top    #3
    AnnaK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Eastern Pennsylvania
    Posts
    1,132
    Yep! The chlorine test is a DPD test with liquid reagents and the colour tube. I am not fond of that at all. I love the TF-100 DPD powder/titration test, it's so much more accurate.


    AnnaK
    — AnnaK —

    12,000 gal AGP, Hayward sand filter, Pentair 2-speed pump, timer.
    Please visit our Pool Issues pages for information about step weights, managing the solar cover, and PoolSkim.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •