Pool Resurfacing, Re-Tiling Costing

sohnsat

New member
Mar 16, 2021
3
Centerton, Arkansas
Hi TFP,

I just became the proud owner of an in-ground, salt-chlorinated Gunite swimming pool. It is approximately 23,000 gallons and has a pretty steep decline into the deep end. There is roughly 210 SQFT at average depth of 4 feet, and 309 SQFT at average depth of 7 feet. It has an~95 linear feet perimeter, and approximately 1,200 SQFT of surface area (walls+floor). It has one skimmer, and the deep-end drain is non-operational. The climate here is low single digit winters, short spring/falls, and 90-105 degree summers of high humidity. I live on flat farm land so sun exposure is high. Not sure on water quality as I am still working on looking at that.

During the inspection phase multiple pool contractors noted the pool needed to be re-surfaced and I agree with them; its a mess. They also noted that while the tiles are functional, they are old/ugly and while they are resurfacing they might as well replace the tile too. I also agree with them on that. No issues with all that. Decking/coping look great.

The issue is cost. Due to the insane growth and building in this area, I was only able to get 3 people that aren't booked out a year or more. Of those 3 only one would apply Diamond Brite and he's a small independent guy that is going to subcontract the plaster work. Said experience is 5 years.

So I am "stuck" (if I want my pool this summer) with a 14,500 to apply a Diamond Brite finish to 1200 SQFT with a subcontractor. They also bid 4,500 to re-tile the ~60 SQFT (95ft by 7 inch tile depth) tile line. By high-end estimates on google the tiling should cost somewhere around $2500 at most depending on materials. The surfacing... not sure. Mostly concerned with the tile work. That seems like double what it should be.

Am I missing something, or is this just out the world high? I'd like to discuss the price with the contractor and see if he can come down, but all I have is google prices which doesn't give me the ammo I need to have an intelligent pricing conversation.

Thanks for any time spent helping!
 
Not quite apples to oranges, but I'm re-plastering and re-tiling in the Dallas area; pool and spa are 130 linear feet, and my best estimate of the volume (it was built 15 years before I bought the place) is around 25000 gallons.

My best estimate for the re-plaster was ~$7100 for quartz, ~$9000 for micropebble, and ~$9800 for whatever they call a pebble-polished-smooth finish. Tile was $2600 for standard tile (plus however much for upgrade tile). At the other end, I had another quote for $9200 for quartz, $2900 for tile. I didn't bother asking about upgraded finishes or tile from them :)

Went with the first estimate, job is due to start tomorrow, which is 9 days from receiving the estimate.
 
Not quite apples to oranges, but I'm re-plastering and re-tiling in the Dallas area; pool and spa are 130 linear feet, and my best estimate of the volume (it was built 15 years before I bought the place) is around 25000 gallons.

My best estimate for the re-plaster was ~$7100 for quartz, ~$9000 for micropebble, and ~$9800 for whatever they call a pebble-polished-smooth finish. Tile was $2600 for standard tile (plus however much for upgrade tile). At the other end, I had another quote for $9200 for quartz, $2900 for tile. I didn't bother asking about upgraded finishes or tile from them :)

Went with the first estimate, job is due to start tomorrow, which is 9 days from receiving the estimate.
Yeah, those are around what Google is saying. Brutal. I guess I'll have the guys that are booked out a year+ come bid and hopefully be able to just sit out a year to get a much better price or higher quality finish for the money.
 
If the pool is usable as it stands, I'd wait it out. That's basically what we did -- bought the place two years ago, first year gutted the old equipment & put in variable speed pump, salt water cell & automation. The plaster and tile were workable, just old and a bit unsightly. This year we had more plaster damaged by the freeze & power outage, so we decided it was time to replaster.
 
Hey Chuck,

Just wanted to say thank you for replying and giving me some real life confirmation that google's data is right for someone within Arkansas distance. I was able to call around to some adjacent states, get some bids over the phone with my measurements and pictures, and secure a much better arrangement of $15,000 for the pool+tile. It isn't the average because they have to travel with all the stuff here, but unfortunately in this market it's what I am stuck with. Much better than $19,000 at least.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.