Just wanted to drop in again and say thanks for all the help.
I'm exactly 30 days post-plaster and everything is looking good so far. You are correct, bmoreswim, it's rewarding to dump in exactly XXoz of MA and to test it later to find it exactly on point.
I let the pucks dissolve completely and that got my CYA to 30. I went in and "field dressed" the Nature 2 Cartridge (removed the metal pack) and have been testing fairly frequently. I eventually had to buy some calcium chloride online as ice melt, which wasn't too bad (about $30 shipped for a 50lb bag). I've slowly added about 25lbs so far over the past several weeks. My last full test of everything was on Sunday, and they were:
Water temp 50
FC: 2 (bumped up to 4 after test)
CC: 0
TA: 70
pH: 7.5
CH: 200
CYA: 30
It's crystal clear water. I swear at night I could probably read a book on the bottom of the deep end from on the waterfall.
We're about to leave for Christmas for a few days, so I thought I would slowly adjust my CYA up to 40-50 and get my chlorine up. I'm not losing much FC each day, but I would guess I need to boost it up quite a bit before we leave to allow for it to drift down over the next 4 days.
Will my CH will continue to rise on its own from the new plaster, or after 30 days will it be done?
Much thanks again to everyone. I'm so glad I did my own research, as we just did "Pool School" the other day, "Yeah you have a Nature 2...so you only need to keep FC at like .5"