The pool cleaner that came with my home purchase 8 months ago is on its last legs. It is an older model hayward that worked well until now. I have a small pool and a suction style is fine for our needs. Any thoughts on the Navigator? I've heard good and bad. Thanks!
Hayward Navigator opinions?
- Thread starter Jmerich
- Start date
In my experience, the Navigator and it's multitude of variations do one of the best jobs of cleaning a pool. The downside is that they are the worst for longevity. Plan on replacing parts every 12 to 18 months.Jmerich said:
I tend to drift towards the types that have one moving part - like the Barracuda and my favorite, the Pentair Kreepy Kruiser. The Kruiser is the only vac I know of that comes with a 2 year warranty.
- May 3, 2007
- 16,878
- Pool Size
- 20000
- Surface
- Plaster
- Chlorine
- Salt Water Generator
- SWG Type
- Hayward Aqua Rite (T-15)
Hayward just purchased ThePoolCleaner so they must think it is a pretty good cleaner. IMHO, it is a better cleaner than the Navigator and it has lasted me over 8 years so far.
I started with a Kreepy Krauler, cleaned well just always getting stuck in my pool. Replaced it with a Navigator about 7 years ago, works but like other say it is Pool Shops dream.... I have replaced almost everything other than the hoses and other shell at least 3 times, shoes and flaps are lucky to last a year. Parts really add up on this thing.
When I told my pool shop owner I just bought the Poolcleaner, he looked upset and told me I would not be happy and that the parts are way more expensive than the Navigator..... I guessing is angered by seeing another customer get clean from a navigator replacement parts addiction.
I based my purchase of the Poolcleaner on countless positive reviews.... So I am hopeful that is works as well as every says.
Doug
When I told my pool shop owner I just bought the Poolcleaner, he looked upset and told me I would not be happy and that the parts are way more expensive than the Navigator..... I guessing is angered by seeing another customer get clean from a navigator replacement parts addiction.
I based my purchase of the Poolcleaner on countless positive reviews.... So I am hopeful that is works as well as every says.
Doug
I have the Navigator Pro XL. I was initially not a fan, but going through my learning curve and lets say a unit Break-in period, I'm pleasantly surprised with the performance; I'll give it a 7 of 10. Using original internal parts/flaps since December 2012 with no issues since. I've found replacement parts on-line inexpensive. If you care to read, my saga is here http://www.troublefreepool.com/threads/52886-Hayward-Navigator-Problems-Solved
Also, to keep the trash from the pump-strainer, I recommend the in-line leaf strainer. http://www.bestbuypoolsupply.com/media/W560.jpg
I've had ThePoolCleaner for 3.5 years now and the only parts that I have replaced are the tires at the end of last summer.