Help with filter replacement

[flyboytfp]

Today noticed leak on backside of PXC125 filter about 1 inch below intake port. Stream is the size of small needle.
Was going to replace with same however they say that this model has been discontinued. So maybe now is good time to try something better. No problems, however.
How say you Sand, DE, Cartilage?
Which brand/model you like?
Pool is about 11,200 gal. Pebble, AO smith 1.5 HP single speed, Hayward SWG.
Your suggestions appreciated. Jim

 

[Charlie_R]

For your application, sand or DE.

Sand will last forever, but won't grab the really fine particles.

DE will filter finer gunk, but will require more maintenance.

 

[alanpaul]

FBtfp,
If you like Cartridge filters, which you've had, I'd consider upgrading to a 150 sq. foot, or even 200 sq. feet, for less frequent cleanings. Also, for simplicity, you might try to find out if anyone makes a filter that would slip right in with your plumbing, requiring little or no modification to your pipes.

Regarding DE: minimum 36 sq. feet, but some people who've never used one before do not appreciate the mess of cleaning it, backwashing, and replacing DE. The filters themselves can be costly upfront, and some plumbing changes are generally required.

I'm not a fan of sand filters, so you'll need to get someone else's recommendations on Sand.

Personally, I've had DE, now I have a cartridge. I think they both are convenient and work very well. A cartridge, with a cup or so of DE added, is less work for similar filtration, in my opinion.

I hope you get exactly what you want, at a great price, with an easy installation.

 

[jblizzle]

General recommendations would be a minimum of:
166 sqft cartridge
20" diameter sand
31 sqft DE

 

[flyboytfp]

Thanks every one. Helpful input.
Any experience with Jandy CS200?
Jim

 

[flyboytfp]

General recommendations would be a minimum of:
166 sqft cartridge
20" diameter sand
31 sqft DE

Thanks everybody. Looking at sand filters, these two: Hayward S244T Pro Top Mount 24" with 1.5" Vari-Flo Valve and Triton II TR 49 GPM 2.46 SF and I think 2" Hi Flow Valve Side Mount.
Please comment on these two items for me to consider.
Any comments on using Zeosand?
Do I have too much Motor/Pump for my pool filter? Looking at this entair Whisper-Flo Pump, Med. Head, Up-Rated, EE, 1 HP, Model WFE-24, 115/230v.
Comments Please.
Thanks Jim

 

[flyboytfp]

:-D All comments appreciated. Thanks Jim