Filter lifespan - Buy new grid cartridge or buy new filter?

azxd09

0
Apr 22, 2011
17
Gilbert, AZ
Here is my situation. I have an 8 year old Sta-rite SMD S7MD60 DE filter, and recently DE and dirt began being blown into the pool returns on occasion. Upon inspection of the DE grid cartridge, I noticed several tears that will require a new grid cartridge. Unfortunately this old Sta-rite model did not have individual grids, but rather had one large cartridge that included all 60 sq. feet in one cartridge. I have found the cartridge online with a best price of ~$260. I have also priced new filter systems at around $600. I am torn between which option makes the most sense. My two questions below are:

1. If I replace the DE grids on my current filter for $260, how many more years of reasonable life can I expect out of my existing filter housing and backwash valve? I have the unit shaded from the sun, but at the same time it is 8 years old. Any replacement parts going forward will be very expensive.

2. What kind of life expectancy can I expect on a new filter? I am actually looking at getting a Hayward sand filter as dealing with this DE has been kind of a nightmare.

3. Given my scenario of $260 for a replacement cartridge now vs. $600 for a new filter, which option would you recommend?

Thanks all for the help!
 
Re: Filter lifespan - Buy new grid cartridge or buy new filt

More than the price difference, it seems like you have had issues with the DE. A new grid cartridge may not alleviate that.

DE works fine for many, many people but if there is something that doesn't make it right for you, I would switch to sand.
 
Re: Filter lifespan - Buy new grid cartridge or buy new filt

Thanks for the feedback guys. I really appreciate it. It helps knowing my filter has some life left in it. I think I will just replace the DE grid. My "nightmare with DE" was just more to illustrate that if I was going to go with a new filter I would lean more towards sand.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.