Become a TFP Supporter Pool Math Forum Rules Pool School
Results 1 to 14 of 14

Thread: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

  1. Back To Top    #1

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Let me start by introducing myself, my name is Nick and I live in Pittsburgh, Pa.

    In april of this year, the wife and I bought a home with an old in ground pool. We knew a pool was a lot of work, but boy were we in for a rude awakening...

    The pool is old, Concrete, and has issues. First issue is that the only plumbing inside the pool, is the main drain, which does work, although I can not get my pump to hold a prime when i select the main drain as the inlet source. The other plumbing comes in the form of PVC piping dropping over the side of the pool with a skimmer attached, and an outlet for the pump. So as of right now are only using the skimmer as the intake for the pump, because if I select the main drain, or both in my valve, it will not hold a prime after shut down. Other issues include, I can not get my vacuum to work through the skimmer, I have tried and tried, but it just isn't very good suction. The skimmer does an excellent job of skimming, but the vacuum is terrible. So to solve that issue I bought an Aquabot robotic pool cleaner on amazon, initially it solve all of my problems, and kept me from insanity in those early weeks of owning a pool. It died after 6 weeks, and I can not get aquabot to reply to my emails. so i have just been brushing my bottom of my pool for algae, and using my skimmer to keep it clean enough... other issues include, the pump is old and need replaced, the pool is not visually appealing to me, and has been known to leak, wasn't mentioned in home inspection, but the neighbors told me all about it and the previous home owner after I moved in.

    Here is where I am at in my decision making process:

    I would like the pool to look modern and I would like for everything to work. I would also like the decking around the pool to be nicer than the current 40 year old concrete that is there with caulking everywhere. So maybe a vinyl liner, new skimmer installed into the wall, new inlets and outlets in waller, new pump, and maybe a heater. Those things I estimate would cost $15-$20k. I am currently in a position where I do have the money to do that, but $20k could go a long way to my retirement.

    The argument for filling it in stems from this, I live inside the city as per my job requirement (firefighter). There fore I have a standard city lot, and my back yard consists of 3 things, A deck, an in ground pool, and about an 8x40 area of grass. If i were to fill in the pool i would have much more yard for the kids to play in when they get older. I was also told it would be about $2500 to fill in the pool, which is way cheaper than $20k to redo it.

    What do you guys think?

    IMG_0274.jpg

  2. Back To Top    #2
    Mod Squad jblizzle's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Tucson, AZ
    Posts
    37,389

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    I do not think you are going to find many advocates for filling in a pool on this forum.

    Were there other plumbing pipes through the walls that have been abandoned? The current setup is certainly a bit odd.
    Jason, TFP Moderator
    18k IG pebblesheen pool, Hayward ProLogic P4 w/ T-15 SWG, Pentair 1HP 2-speed Superflo, Hayward 6020 DE filter
    500 sqft Heliocol solar panels, ThePoolCleaner, TF-100 test kit w/ SpeedStir
    Pool School + Test Kit + PoolMath = A TROUBLE FREE POOL
    If you found TFP helpful and we saved you money ... Become a TFP Supporter!

  3. Back To Top    #3

    In the Industry

    duraleigh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Sebring, Florida
    Posts
    30,084

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    I also think your fill-it-in estimate is optimistic. People on this forum report costs almost as high as the remodel. I don't know that for sure but I would get a firm price before I started any demolition.
    Dave S.
    42k vinyl and concrete pool, 1.5hp pump, 140gpm filter
    TFTestkits , PoolMath , Pool School

  4. Back To Top    #4

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Quote Originally Posted by jblizzle View Post
    I do not think you are going to find many advocates for filling in a pool on this forum.

    Were there other plumbing pipes through the walls that have been abandoned? The current setup is certainly a bit odd.
    The only physical holes in the pool itself is the main drain, which is functional. But there are 2 pipes coming out of the ground near the pump, one for the main drain, and the old home owner told me that the other one was broken under ground and is no longer used. I believe there had to be some sort of plumbing built into the walls at some point, such as a skimmer and or outlets for the pump. I don't know if maybe they filled them in before they painted it or something? I am going to have the local pool company, Alpine Pools, come out and give me an estimate on updating this pool. Do you guys have any feedback as to whether or not it will cost a fortune? Also can you give me any feedback on giving this pool a cantilevered edge to make it look more modern, is it something I could have a landscaper do, or potentially do myself?

    - - - Updated - - -

    IMG_0269.jpg

    - - - Updated - - -

    I would really love to save this pool, not many city folk like me have an in ground pool! My son is 1 year old, and I know when he is older we will have a blast in the pool. I am just worried that It will cost far more than it is worth. Most of the remodels I can find online, the old pool at least had a skimmer in the wall... I am really disappointed in my decision to buy a house with an in ground pool and not do my research first...

  5. Back To Top    #5
    Mod Squad Jimrahbe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Bedford, TX
    Posts
    5,330

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    A 3rd option would be to use the pool for one more year "as is" and not make a decision right now. My guess is that your existing pool would be a lot more fun if you weren't fighting algae all the time.

    So, remodel it for $25K, fill it in for $5K, or invest about $100 in a TF-100, and a little time on this site. Pretty easy pick for me.

    I also suggest you contact Amazon about your Aquabot robotic pool cleaner. They generally have an amazing return policy and even if that is not in the cards, they might be able to get Aquabot to respond. A robot is definitely the way to go vs. manual vacuuming.

    This time, next year, you may feel much differently about your options.

    Good luck with your decision...

    Jim R.
    Finished in 2015 - 17K Gal, IG, 20' x 25' Almost Rectangular Pool, Pebble finish, three rockport water falls. Pentair Equipment: EasyTouch 4, IC40 SWG, 3 HP VS Pump, CCP520 Cartridge Filter.
    TF100 with SpeedStir and SampleSizer, ColorQ Pro 7, Dolphin Premier Robot Cleaner, added Screen Logic 2, added small 3 person Calder Spa.

  6. Back To Top    #6
    kellyfair's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    173

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    I think I would look into the cost for getting things working properly, and worry about aesthetics later on. The look of the pool might not be as big an issue if the frustration of it not working right was gone.
    Kelly, Tampa FL
    15' by 4' Intex above ground metal frame, about 5300 gallons
    Intex 120V Krystal Clear Sand Filter Pump & Saltwater System CG-28679 with E.C.O.
    TF100 Kit and Speedstir
    Intex Auto Cleaner - works great!

  7. Back To Top    #7

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    True, if things were working properly, I would feel so much better about this pool.

  8. Back To Top    #8

    Join Date
    Dec 2015
    Location
    Hawera, Taranaki, New Zealand
    Posts
    443

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    I love Jim's idea of running as is for a year and see how you feel and if you are pool people. Then if you do want to keep it maybe you could upgrade / remodel to what you want over a period of time instead of all at once, spreading the cost. You would also have a better idea of what you would want / need in a pool.

    Sent from my C1904 using Tapatalk

    Edit
    I know that there are plenty of people here who can offer advice on how to get your equipment and pool running in the most cost effective manner and relieve a lot of that frustration. All you need to do is ask
    6000 gal, AG vinyl, Intex ultra frame 16ft, 1200 Gallon Sand Filter, DIY Solar, Clear Choice Labs Testing Kit

  9. Back To Top    #9

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pleasanton, CA
    Posts
    10

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    How old are your kids?
    When the kids reach the middle school/high school years a pool is a great activity to enjoy with friends. We have a 9, 12 and 14 yr old and are looking into putting a pool in for that reason.

  10. Back To Top    #10

    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Pittsburgh, PA
    Posts
    98

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Nick,

    A fellow Pittsburgher... DO NOT CALL Alpine! You'll be sold on how terrible your pool is and how you need a new drop in replacement fiberglass pool.

    I was in a similar situation last year. An older pool with the same piping setup. We had PVC pipes coming over the top for a skimmer/return. It was going to cost us $10-12k to break up the concrete and fill in the pool, verses $16k to completely rehab the pool.

    Call Joe at Choice Pools to do this, that's who we used and were extremely satisfied. He does a lot of these rehab type things. I think what they'd do is this:
    1) Bust up the concrete and poke holes in the shell install a skimmer and returns.
    2) Run new plumbing
    3) If the shell is intact and holding water I wouldn't do a liner. Keep as-is
    4) Replace the concrete patio

    Based on what we paid for our work which was very similar I would think your cost would be about the same, potentially less because you don't need a liner.

    I looked at the math on this and said to myself "I could pay $10k for grass and to remove a pool, or an additional $6k for a working pool. Would I want a pool if I could buy one for $6k?"

    Nate
    In-ground 15x30 concrete pool with vinyl liner
    Triton II sand filter, Hayward Pump, Raypak 266 heater
    Rehab thread: Pool rehab, need advice

  11. Back To Top    #11

    Join Date
    May 2015
    Location
    Land O Lakes, FL
    Posts
    526

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Pool or Yard for kids as they grow? Pool all the way!!!!

    We got a pool this year because I have kids (7 kids ages 3-16) and they swim in it almost every day and often for hours at a time. Then they sleep really well. I love it too. As a kid, I had pools growing up and they were very frequently used. During the summer late spring and summer, almost everyday.

    I would also consider the project in phases. Maybe get the pump & plumbing working and then consider the remodel. If they have to pull up the concrete to fix the plumbing, then maybe consider going all the way.
    Matt
    2016 Pool Build: 12k IG Blue Granite Pebblesheen, Travertine Coping & Pavers, Pentair IntelliFlo, Intellichlor, Easytouch, Clean & Clear 320, Heliocol Solar - TF-100 test kit w/ SpeedStir
    SWG Run Time Calculator

  12. Back To Top    #12

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Quote Originally Posted by mgmoore7 View Post
    Pool or Yard for kids as they grow? Pool all the way!!!!

    We got a pool this year because I have kids (7 kids ages 3-16) and they swim in it almost every day and often for hours at a time. Then they sleep really well. I love it too. As a kid, I had pools growing up and they were very frequently used. During the summer late spring and summer, almost everyday.

    I would also consider the project in phases. Maybe get the pump & plumbing working and then consider the remodel. If they have to pull up the concrete to fix the plumbing, then maybe consider going all the way.
    Thanks for the advice, with all of the feedback, it seems I actually have some direction. I may just close it for the year and start fresh in the spring. I am going away for a month and when I return it will be cold outside.



  13. Back To Top    #13

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    Quote Originally Posted by ntobik View Post
    Nick,

    A fellow Pittsburgher... DO NOT CALL Alpine! You'll be sold on how terrible your pool is and how you need a new drop in replacement fiberglass pool.

    I was in a similar situation last year. An older pool with the same piping setup. We had PVC pipes coming over the top for a skimmer/return. It was going to cost us $10-12k to break up the concrete and fill in the pool, verses $16k to completely rehab the pool.

    Call Joe at Choice Pools to do this, that's who we used and were extremely satisfied. He does a lot of these rehab type things. I think what they'd do is this:
    1) Bust up the concrete and poke holes in the shell install a skimmer and returns.
    2) Run new plumbing
    3) If the shell is intact and holding water I wouldn't do a liner. Keep as-is
    4) Replace the concrete patio

    Based on what we paid for our work which was very similar I would think your cost would be about the same, potentially less because you don't need a liner.

    I looked at the math on this and said to myself "I could pay $10k for grass and to remove a pool, or an additional $6k for a working pool. Would I want a pool if I could buy one for $6k?"

    Nate
    Thanks for your advice, called them and left a message.



  14. Back To Top    #14

    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    23

    Re: Remodel my pool or fill it in, help me decide!

    I have been in contact with Choice Pools thanks to Ntobik's recommendation. I got a quote from them and I would like to run it by you guys to see if everything sounds fair. First let me start by saying that keeping the pool for one more year is no longer an option. It is currently empty as it has been leaking all summer slowly and I didn't realize it and just kept adding water. So with that being said it is empty and just sitting by idle until I make a decision. I got prices on several different things as to cover every aspect of this remodel since I am not sure how far I want to go with cost.

    Joe from choice pools told me that in all of his years of doing in ground pools, he has never seen one with no plumbing at all cut into the walls, very interesting.

    Here is the quote, let me know your thoughts.





    A new liner in the pool will cost $3570



    I would cut the concrete pool wall to install a skimmer and return as well as an area on the concrete to plumb in the new skimmer. After the new fixtures are installed I would pour concrete in the disturbed areas. The cost to install the fixtures and repair the cement is $3850.


    The filter pad would be relocated behind the fence where a new electric line will need to be run by an electrician.


    All of the concrete could be removed around the pool and repoured with a concrete bull nosed coping. The cost to redo all of the concrete around the pool would be $9800.


    Pavers could be laid over the existing pool deck at a cost of $9200


    If either option of redoing the pool deck is desired we would need to use the neighbors driveway for entry in the pool area. The neighbor’s yard will need reseeded after and will cost $1400 to repair.


    An automatic pool cover could be installed on the pool with a bench at the end for the cover to be stored. Cost for an automatic pool cover is $8350.


    We could cut the concrete at the end of the pool and install a box in the ground to house the cover instead of a bench at the end of the pool which would add $2800 to the automatic pool cover.


    An electrician would need to run power for the automatic pool cover.


    If you would decide to install a liner as an option, you could add a set of corner steps for the liner to go over and eliminate the ladder for exit and entry. The cost for a corner step in the pool is $2300.


    Thank you,
    Joakim Lowenadler

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •