The best lens gasket to use will be from the manufacturer (pentair) it is usually vanilla in color, and will fit snugly around lens, for a do it yourself repair attempt you cant go wrong with starting fresh with a new gasket. The sealing problem usually has nothing to do with the light can, or the various parts that keep it sealed, but everything to do with improper reassembly, so...#1) THE RUBBER GASKET IS FOR THE GLASS LENS ONLY...#2) THERE HAS TO BE "SIX" SMALL BRACKETS THAT HANG LOOSELY FROM THE FACE RING, EACH OF THEM ARE USED TO SUPPORT THE WIRE CLAMP AND "SIX" ARE NEEDED FOR THE PROPER TENSION TO SEAL THE LENS PROPERLY, IF ONLY "FIVE" ARE THERE THE CLAMP WILL MAX OUT AND USE ALL OF ITS RANGE OF TIGHTENING ABILITY, AND IF THERE ARE "SIX" AND THE WIRE CLAMP FALLS OFF ONE OF THE "SIX" AS YOU TIGHTEN IT, THIS WILL ALSO MAX OUT THE TENSION RANGE OF THE CLAMP, MAKE SURE YOU INSPECT BEHIND THE FACE RING TO VERIFY THE WIRE CLAMP HAS MADE CONTACT WITH ALL "SIX" IT IS VERY EASY TO BEGIN TO TIGHTEN CLAMP AND NOT REALIZE ONE OF THE BRACKETS HAS SLIPPED OFF, ALWAYS VERIFY THE WIRE CLAMP CRADLES ALL "SIX" #3) DO NOT LUBRICATE GASKET, OR USE SILICONE OF ANY KIND, THESE LIGHTS ARE DRY SEALED, AND THE REASON BEHIND THE DECISION TO RESORT TO USING LUBRICATION CAN BE TRACED TO #1 OR #2 ABOVE This info is specific to the full size pentair amerilite style pool light, in its original factory condition, unmolested by hammers, vise grip,s, etc.