Search results

  1. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    Well, green to red is the problem. That is the most common form of color blindness. I can generally distinguish between bright red and bright green, but when they are both light pastels they are very difficult to distinguish.
  2. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    You may be right. I've constantly fought rising pH over the years. I generally add acid on a weekly basis to keep pH in the 7.5-7.8 range, and I've added borates to establish a buffer. It could probably use some more borates, which I hope to bolster with the addition of 20 Mule Borax after the...
  3. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    Unfortunately, I don't use a proper test kit. I'm color blind, so I just use a TruTest strip reader to get keep my FC and PH in range. It's generally good enough for my purposes.
  4. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    Maybe, but my autofill comes from a separate water supply. The main is branched to an irrigation line before the water enters the house. I don't really want a softener just for the pool, and it would take a fair bit of plumbing to install the softener between the sprinkler manifold and the...
  5. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    Yeah, their results are pretty questionable. I basically use their tests as a rough guide and sanity check for my own testing (which is also suspect). I generally just shoot for a range and I don't really have any problems. Still, it's nice to know that the fill water is relatively low. The...
  6. P

    Digital pool chemistry measuring - color blind

    I had the same problem when I first got my pool ~17 years ago. I purchased an AquaChek TruTest meter. It's pretty basic in that it only measures FC, PH, and TA. However, I find that those three are sufficient for basic day-to-day pool maintenance. I go to the pool store about once a month or so...
  7. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    You're probably right. Just not sure because So. Cal. gets water from a number of different sources, and the CO river has been cutting back deliveries because of the western drought. FWIW, I found the water quality report for my agency, but they don't list iron levels. My Leslies pool store...
  8. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    Thank you for the insights. I guess I will try a sequestering agent first. What type of concentration rise do you think I might see without doing anything. I had my water measured at Leslies (I know, I know, but I don't have any other way or measuring metals), and it came back as 0.1 ppm each of...
  9. P

    First time Ascorbic Acid treatment -- Should I use a sequestrant, CuLator, or both?

    I did a spot test with AA from Duda, and it seems to be effective. I'm gonna wait about another week to let my FC drop near zero, and I figured I could do some prep in the meantime. I've read through the guide a couple of times and will reread it a few more times. I'd prefer to pull the metals...
  10. P

    Looking for recommendations to replace Pentair IC40 system

    As far as I remember, the warranty on cells is only 12 months. Fortunately, it appears that the cell is still functioning properly. That's interesting about the hydrogen. I might have to play with that a bit.
  11. P

    Looking for recommendations to replace Pentair IC40 system

    I usually only have to clean it once a year. I typically do that in late November after the annual Santa Ana winds in California. Those winds tend to blow a lot of dust and debris into the pool. Once a year might seem insufficient, but my pressure rise barely changes from clean to dirty. Might...
  12. P

    Looking for recommendations to replace Pentair IC40 system

    Just updating this thread in case anyone might be interested. It seems that the root cause of my problem may be a small leak somewhere on the intake side of the pump. I have a VS pump, and at low speeds, I noticed some small bubbles coming out of the pool jets. This normally indicates chlorine...
  13. P

    Looking for recommendations to replace Pentair IC40 system

    Thanks Jim. I haven't had time to really dig into it just yet. I just noticed about 5-6 weeks ago that my chlorine levels were reading very close to zero when I checked it on the weekend. Typically, I keep it in the 4-7 ppm range. 9 days ago, the FC was around 3, and I added about ~16 oz of...
  14. P

    Looking for recommendations to replace Pentair IC40 system

    Still troubleshooting, but it appears that my IC40 is failing again. This cell has only been installed for two years, but all of a sudden it can't keep up. I'm tired of the frequent failures and high replacement costs. I've never had a cell last longer than 3 years. Does anyone have...
  15. P

    Should I replace my 15-year old filter cartridges?

    Thanks for the input. You may be correct. I'll do a careful inspection when I clean them this year and reconsider my decision then. On a side note, I wonder if my low-speed filtration strategy has significantly extended the life of these filters. It would kind of make sense that being exposed...
  16. P

    Should I replace my 15-year old filter cartridges?

    Agreed. Wasn't really looking to buy OEM. Pleatcos are probably at least as good as the original filters.
  17. P

    Should I replace my 15-year old filter cartridges?

    Yeah, I was thinking of that, but then I'd need to purchase a container just for that purpose. The cost isn't too big a deal, but hard to justify for something I'd only use once every 5 years or so. I'd also need to find a place to store it.
  18. P

    Should I replace my 15-year old filter cartridges?

    Well, as far as I can tell the gauge is reading 2-3 psi. However, you really can't trust most pressure gauges below ~10% of the full-scale reading, which in my case is 60 psi. Even in the middle of the range, accuracy is typically somewhere around 2% of full scale, which would be around +/- 1.2...
  19. P

    Should I replace my 15-year old filter cartridges?

    Pentair CCP 520, still on original cartridges. Pressure on low/slow pump rate (around 1200 RPM) is well under 5 psi. When I run my pump for skimming (around 2200 RPM), my the gauge reads 11-13 psi. These numbers have been fairly consistent for the last 5-6 years, at least. I typically clean my...
  20. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    I suppose you're right. I'm not very familiar with cap start motors. I normally work with DC and VFD/servo drives so I never deal with caps for motor rotation.
  21. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    I'm not sure I understand your circuit. During rotation when neither switch is open, both the red and white terminals are connected to black.
  22. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    To further elaborate on the possible logic, each switch has two states which I will call ON or OFF. Since there are two switches, there are four combinations of SW1 ON/OFF and SW2 ON/OFF. The control circuit will look at the combination (and possibly how one combination changes to another...
  23. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    I'm mostly guessing about how the switches work, but I suspect that the power to the actuators does not actually flow through the switches. I'm probably biased because I work on automation equipment for a living, and it would normally be considered dangerous to route power through limit...
  24. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    Can't really know without a schematic. The reversing relay may be distinct from the switches themselves. So the direction may be determined by the relative state of each switch at the time the contacts are made. When you touch the the connectors together, you may be closing the Normally Open...
  25. P

    Pentair Actuator acting strange

    I had a very similar problem develop with my 14-year old actuator. Works in one direction, but doesn't stop in the other direction. I'm pretty sure that the problem is a bad microswitch. This video is a good resource for how to fix it. You might want to try this before replacing the whole...
  26. P

    Advice on Testing for the Colorblind

    I'm red-green colorblind and I've been using the AquaChek TruTest meter for the last 14 years. https://www.amazon.com/Aqua-Chek-Trutest-Digital-Reader/dp/B000RZNKNW It's not perfect by any stretch, but it's accurate enough for me to get a general sense of how the water is doing. I supplement...
  27. P

    High CH, need advice on pool draining options.

    I've never done it, but I recall hearing about a service that will come to your home and run your pool water through a reverse-osmosis filter. Might be an option in AZ. Probably pretty expensive compared to just replacing the water, but some areas might have water usage restrictions.
  28. P

    Calcium hardness

    I've had CH of 500+ in my pool ever since it was built 13 years ago. I don't think it has caused any issues other than minor waterline scaling. I've done partial drains a couple of times when it got over 1000, but I don't think I've ever gotten it below 400. My fill water is probably around 100...
  29. P

    Pentair IC40 vs IChlor 30

    Thanks everyone. For each of my failed units, it's basically been a persistent "Clean Cell" LED indicator that led to a total lack of chlorine production. The first two that died, I had zero scaling, yet the Clean Cell light kept returning. Each of those cells lasted about 18 months (the second...
  30. P

    Pentair IC40 vs IChlor 30

    I need to replace an IC40 cell for the 4th time in 13 years. It would probably be the fifth time except that I used liquid chlorine for about 3-4 of those 13 years. I'm wondering if the IChlor 30 might be a better choice in terms of reliabitily and longevity. Anyone have recent...