Smooth pool surface (LA, CA)

southbay

Member
Nov 9, 2019
15
Los Angeles, CA
I am ready to plaster and looking for a smooth, darker pool surface - dark french grey or something with dark blue water. Color like a Kenai Grey or Silver Reef a Microfusion Midnight. However I can't figure out the right way to get there.

My PB says I need to tile if I want smooth but that ship has sailed. He has only done one or two Polishedscapes and had zero feedback or recommendations on them. I suppose he might do it if I press, but since the skill and experience of the applicant matters so much, I don't have faith in a high quality outcome. There have already been other issues I've had to deal with. He wants me to go with a pebble.

I've called a few plasterers who say different things:
- One used to do Hydrazzo but stopped due to product issues. They say they now polish Mini Pebble, however they have only done light colors like white and can't guarantee a darker color will work.
- A friend's PB says PolishedScapes and Quartzscapes are better, but recommends polishing Stonescapes because it "won't mottle" like the first two. He said Quartz can burn and create streaks so don't polish that one.
- I spoke with an NPT rep and they don't recommend polishing Stonescapes or anything except Polishedscapes, which are specifically formulated.

I've read the post that non-white plaster should use inorganic pigments for longevity, but haven't found a way to determine the type of pigment in a certain mix.
I've also read that lighter colors are the way to go, but my wife wants darker.
I've read every "polished" thread I can find on here multiple times, but it seems like such a minority of builds it's hard to get good info.

I'm about ready to give up on my dream of smooth and go with a darker micro or mini pebble and live with it. Anyone have any suggestions for me before I throw in the towel? Or an experienced plasterer/polisher in Los Angeles who can get me what I want?

thank you.
 
Darker plaster is almost guaranteed to mottle which gets customers complaining. Plaster companies don’t want the complaints so they are all steering you to light color low complaint finishes.

You need to prioritize what you want. Smooth surface with dark color and mottling will just add character to the look? Then tell the plasters you understand about mottling and will accept it to get your smooth dark finish.
 
Last edited:
I have had Hydrazoo smooth finished for 25 years. I last replastered with Hydrazoo 7 years ago and it went well. I don’t know why your guy is dumping on Hydrazoo. It is a nice smooth finish and takes an extra day with power sanders to finish it.

I suggest you contact CL Industries and see what installers of Hydrazoo they recommend in your area.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.