bobodaclown wrote:
She thought that was a silly analogy
This is because the pool industry only talks about CYA as protecting chlorine breakdown from sunlight -- a "sunscreen for chlorine". They don't talk about how most of the chlorine is bound to CYA making it essentially inactive. That is the dirty little secret that no one wants to talk about because it runs counter to a "CYA doesn't matter" argument that allows for continued sale of Trichlor tablets along with very profitable algaecides, clarifiers and other products that are often needed when the water mysteriously goes south.